Excess Other Account Funds... going back in time
-
- New Member
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2011 6:42 am
- Location: Juneau, Alaska
Excess Other Account Funds... going back in time
As the Stake Finance Clerk i am trying a resolve a issue in one of our remote Branches. currently the root Other Account has a balance of approx. $6,000.00. Of course this is an issue in our audits.
As I researched this I find, in mid year 2007 the balance was $1500.00 (and balanced with te Statement) by end of year it was $8600.00 and this balance carried forward from there. Going back in memories and some old notes this Branch had some major issues transmitting batch donations during this time. The donation batches were mailed in to CHQ (no local bank).
I believe that either the donations during this time were either credited to the Other Account by CHQ as they did not have any transmitted data. For some reason this never resolved at one end or the other.
Support does not have any records to assist, pre CUBS on this, I have the past Unit Audits and old notes to piece together these assumptions. As this was three Branch Presidents ago, no one has any history, and now the Leadership has a perception the money is theirs from other sources.
Does anyone have a recollection that may support or not support my theory on the source of these funds, as to how finances were handled (donation transmission issues)by CHQ during this time period (2007)?
As I researched this I find, in mid year 2007 the balance was $1500.00 (and balanced with te Statement) by end of year it was $8600.00 and this balance carried forward from there. Going back in memories and some old notes this Branch had some major issues transmitting batch donations during this time. The donation batches were mailed in to CHQ (no local bank).
I believe that either the donations during this time were either credited to the Other Account by CHQ as they did not have any transmitted data. For some reason this never resolved at one end or the other.
Support does not have any records to assist, pre CUBS on this, I have the past Unit Audits and old notes to piece together these assumptions. As this was three Branch Presidents ago, no one has any history, and now the Leadership has a perception the money is theirs from other sources.
Does anyone have a recollection that may support or not support my theory on the source of these funds, as to how finances were handled (donation transmission issues)by CHQ during this time period (2007)?
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 3907
- Joined: Mon Sep 24, 2007 9:17 am
- Location: Cumming, GA, USA
Re: Excess Other Account Funds... going back in time
I can't help you on your questions but you can at least squash this idea. 'Other' account funds can only be used for the specific purpose they were originally donated to. If the source of the funds can't be tracked then the funds need to be sent to CHQ. See the comment at the end of the this article: https://www.lds.org/callings/melchizede ... y?lang=eng (you'll need to log onto your LDS Account to see the article). Although that is a user comment it can easily be confirmed by contacting Local Unit Support.mschlechter wrote:As this was three Branch Presidents ago, no one has any history, and now the Leadership has a perception the money is theirs from other sources.
It would, of course, be best if you can identify the original source. But in almost every scenario I can think of you'll just end up sending the funds to CHQ. If they were supposed to be tithing and fast offering donations you can't correct the original transactions at this point so you'll just have to send a check to CHQ. If the donations were for a member financed activity you're unlikely to be able to determine who should receive refunds at this point either so you'll probably have to do the same.
The one thing that isn't allowed is for the branch to just use the money for whatever they want.
-
- Community Moderators
- Posts: 11460
- Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2008 10:27 pm
- Location: US
Re: Excess Other Account Funds... going back in time
Your recollection is correct. Pre-CUBS, when a deposit was made but there was not a corresponding transmission, Headquarters put the money in the Other account until they received the transmission, then transferred it from Other to the correct categories. It is quite likely this happened in the situation you describe, and then the matter was never resolved.mschlechter wrote:. . . this Branch had some major issues transmitting batch donations during this time. The donation batches were mailed in to CHQ (no local bank).
I believe that either the donations during this time were either credited to the Other Account by CHQ as they did not have any transmitted data. For some reason this never resolved at one end or the other.
As eblood66 said, the branch should identify the specific purpose of the funds they believe are theirs (Scouts, YW camp, magazine drive, etc.), and then they should write a check on the Other account for the difference and send the money to Headquarters.
-
- Community Administrator
- Posts: 34422
- Joined: Sat Jan 20, 2007 2:53 pm
- Location: U.S.
Re: Excess Other Account Funds... going back in time
I wonder what that did to the year-end tax reports given to the members.lajackson wrote:It is quite likely this happened in the situation you describe, and then the matter was never resolved.
Have you searched the Help Center? Try doing a Google search and adding "site:churchofjesuschrist.org/help" to the search criteria.
So we can better help you, please edit your Profile to include your general location.
So we can better help you, please edit your Profile to include your general location.
- aebrown
- Community Administrator
- Posts: 15153
- Joined: Tue Nov 27, 2007 8:48 pm
- Location: Draper, Utah
Re: Excess Other Account Funds... going back in time
The tax reports were most likely just fine. Before CUBS, all the data involved in the generation of those reports was in the local MLS database.russellhltn wrote:I wonder what that did to the year-end tax reports given to the members.lajackson wrote:It is quite likely this happened in the situation you describe, and then the matter was never resolved.
The OP implies that the donation batches were created with no errors -- the only problem was with the transmission. So MLS would have a donation batch for X dollars that was never successfully transmitted, and CHQ would have detected a deposit of X dollars that didn't correspond to any donation batch that it had received.
The real problem here is that all the funds in the deposit didn't go to the correct destinations. CHQ can only properly sweep funds when it knows where they are to go. So for an untransmitted batch, no funds can be sent to Tithing, or Fast Offering, or General Missionary, etc. at the CHQ level.
The failure to sweep would have no impact on the local records of what happened. But it does seem like it would have made reconciliation impossible (which was a pre-CUBS requirement that every audit should have checked up on), so someone repeatedly dropped the ball in following up on the reconciliation failures.
- gregwanderson
- Senior Member
- Posts: 702
- Joined: Thu Apr 15, 2010 10:34 pm
- Location: Huntsville, UT, USA
Re: Excess Other Account Funds... going back in time
Wouldn't it be great if the person who dropped the ball by not reconciling this problem in 2007 also dropped the ball when it came to destroying old, paper records? In other words, what if you could actually find the old paperwork (donation slips, batch reports, etc.) from 2007 in some corner of the branch's office? It might take a couple of hours to look at everything and figure out where the excess money was really supposed to go but, wow. If you had that paperwork you could do it.
-
- New Member
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2011 6:42 am
- Location: Juneau, Alaska
Re: Excess Other Account Funds... going back in time
As the OP I considered that the old records may still be there (and would bet they are). No reconciliation's were done after mid 2007, this was noted in Audits, but not followed up on (complicated story). The Branch had contacted CHQ several times in resolving this also but......
I would gladly dig around for the old records, but the Branch is a 40 minute plane flight each way (no roads, we have a very unique Stake) and I would probably have to stay over for two days to accomplish this. It is just more effective to "draw the line in the sand" and move on from here. Fortunately, I had saved all the old Audits back to 2003 to piece this together, now convincing the Branch President that the money is not theirs is the next obstacle.
I would gladly dig around for the old records, but the Branch is a 40 minute plane flight each way (no roads, we have a very unique Stake) and I would probably have to stay over for two days to accomplish this. It is just more effective to "draw the line in the sand" and move on from here. Fortunately, I had saved all the old Audits back to 2003 to piece this together, now convincing the Branch President that the money is not theirs is the next obstacle.
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 1222
- Joined: Thu Dec 08, 2011 10:42 am
- Location: Emmett, Idaho
Re: Excess Other Account Funds... going back in time
Here are some options I can think of.mschlechter wrote:I would gladly dig around for the old records, but the Branch is a 40 minute plane flight each way (no roads, we have a very unique Stake) and I would probably have to stay over for two days to accomplish this. It is just more effective to "draw the line in the sand" and move on from here. Fortunately, I had saved all the old Audits back to 2003 to piece this together, now convincing the Branch President that the money is not theirs is the next obstacle.
1) Have the Branch Clerk do the research and figure out the problem.
2) Have the Branch Clerk box up the records and send them to you.
3) If you don't have time to travel there maybe another clerk familiar with finances could go and do the research for you.
What does the Branch President plan to do with the money? His options are very limited mostly to youth annual camps or equipment. Being a branch so fare out in the bush I doubt there is enough youth to use the funds in a reasonable amount of time.mschlechter wrote:now convincing the Branch President that the money is not theirs is the next obstacle.
I think having the Stake President tell the Branch President to send the money to the stake while your trying to figure out the correct action to take would be a good thing to do.
-
- New Member
- Posts: 13
- Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2011 6:42 am
- Location: Juneau, Alaska
Re: Excess Other Account Funds... going back in time
Good thoughts, I do know what needs to be done now. Really, just needed the confirmation that un-transmitted deposits went to Other, to confirm the source.Gary_Miller wrote:mschlechter wrote: Here are some options I can think of.
1) Have the Branch Clerk do the research and figure out the problem.
2) Have the Branch Clerk box up the records and send them to you.
3) If you don't have time to travel there maybe another clerk familiar with finances could go and do the research for you.
What does the Branch President plan to do with the money? His options are very limited mostly to youth annual camps or equipment. Being a branch so fare out in the bush I doubt there is enough youth to use the funds in a reasonable amount of time.mschlechter wrote:now convincing the Branch President that the money is not theirs is the next obstacle.
I think having the Stake President tell the Branch President to send the money to the stake while your trying to figure out the correct action to take would be a good thing to do.
I do not think he has a plan with the funds, it has just been sitting there for so many years they have taken ownership of it. Just needed my ducks in a row before presenting my case to the Branch Presidency and to the Stake President if needed that funds are not theirs to use.
Option 1 would be great, but if they were capable of doing so we probably would not have this issue to begin with.
Option 2 good idea, may do that.
Option 3 not a matter of time, just practicality.
In reality this is pretty easy to fix now that have put together all the information. Now back to billing Units for the Stake Youth Conference and Young Womens Camp.....
Thanks
-
- Community Moderators
- Posts: 11460
- Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2008 10:27 pm
- Location: US
Re: Excess Other Account Funds... going back in time
Although all of the untransmitted deposits may have gone to Other, there may also have been some actual Other funds if the branch was collecting for Scout camp, YW camp, or something similar. So I would consider that possibility before I just took all of it away.mschlechter wrote:Good thoughts, I do know what needs to be done now. Really, just needed the confirmation that un-transmitted deposits went to Other, to confirm the source.
I do not think he has a plan with the funds, it has just been sitting there for so many years they have taken ownership of it.